On the other are those who are staunchly anti-fungus and want no such thing on their sandwich. This stuff tastes like sugared air. Some locations may also have other options, but they're either a bit boring (like vanilla or chocolate), or not available in enough locations to fairly rank them. Its just too much vanilla. "This was the only one that didn't taste artificial. Last one I probably had was a shamrock shake maybe 3 years ago. Im not lactose intolerant, but I am human. This shouldve been a slam dunk for Burger King. Sometimes called "Thin Mint" milkshakes or"Grasshopper" milkshakes, these are a classic mix of chocolate and mint. The next closest is nearly two hours away and I like milkshakes (and my job), but not that much. These popular milkshake flavors all have one thing in common:coffee. Or usea different base ice cream (such as mint or strawberry). But even that slightly modified take on the all-American staple isn't enough to make up for the fact that the bun was barely grilled, no part of the meal was seasoned, and at the end of the day, it's still just a plain hot dog. StrawberryFor something so simple, strawberry milkshakes get screwed up at an alarming rate. Sandwiches. Luckily, you dont have to try every fast food milkshake. Others thought the lighter chocolate taste was great. Most people add a tablespoon or so of peanut butter to the blend to get the flavor they love. Peanut butter milkshake =good. The taste of the chocolate milkshake was the most consistent problem for our tasters. I worked there and thats what i got every day. For the most part, the chocolate milkshake at Chick-fil-A was notour pleasure to sip on. Which is great if you mainline coffee all day, every day. Cappuccino. At first, I was not sure how this would taste, but I was pleasantly surprised by how sweet it turned out to be. Through thick and thin, scooped with a spoon or sipped through a straw, chocolate milkshakes are a delicious treat. But its still somehow smooth enough to drink through a straw, so its not really ice cream either so it is kind of a milkshake? If you're going to get one basic from Five Guys, start with the fries. We Tasted 5 Fast-Food Chocolate Milkshakes & This Is the Best. Each time, I saw char on the meat, hand-formed patties that broke apart easily, a well-griddled bun that didnt get soggy, and the exclusive use of American cheese, which is THE ONLY ACCEPTABLE CHEESE on burgers. For more flavor, add peanut butter or chocolate sauce, or top with whipped cream. Lets jump in! Through some strange alchemy, it still manages to hold its thickness for the entire duration of your milkshake, whether youre a fast or slow drinker. See the variations above. A post shared by Tricia Reed (@rfamilyprism). Add a little more on top, and you're good to go. Pick your personal favorite flavor, you cant go wrong here. The flavor here has a strong ice cream-forward quality, which leaves the chocolate a little wanting (its not actually that chocolate-y, but I still like it). It's rich, sweet and just a little salty. However, if you're looking to indulge in cheese and bread, there are other, more rewarding ways to invest those calories. I also gave each shake a rating out of five for thickness (insert obligatory THICC joke here). *Apologies once again to Whataburger and Culvers. One stated that "this tastes more like a black and whitevanilla with a touch of chocolate. Want a recipe? If truly desperate, you can substitute banana flavoring for the banana, but I don't recommend it! Come on this greasy, peanut-oil-infused journey with us to find out. For extra flavor, add in broken peanut butter cups or top with whipped cream and a little chocolate sauce. You can always opt for their classic fries and get the seasoning on the side. Learn to "give a good haircut," "serve a good drink at a bar," or fry up a tasty burger, his mom told him, according to Five Guys. But Ive decided to go with my second favorite, Neopolitan, to prove a larger point about In-N-Out milkshakes. Vanilla . Just as the plain hot dog ranked last among its kind, the plain hamburger simply could not compete with its more dressed-up brethren. Cheese Veggie Sandwich. One editor said this shake was creamy and delicious and that it "tastes like chocolate soft serve. Fresh and bursting with flavor. Stop complaining about In-N-Outs fries, just dip them in the shake its a better experience than the Frosty could ever give you. Top 10 Milkshake Flavor Combos Mint Choco-Chip, Mocha, Peanut Butter and Chocolate and More By Lindsey Goodwin Updated on 06/26/19 Plain milkshakes are great, true -- but nothing beats a great milkshake flavor that mixes things up. Really well, in fact. Starting with this absolute wonder. You could go with caramel sauce instead, or you can replacethe butterscotch with a bit of black strap molasses (black molassesbeing one of the main ingredients in butterscotch) or abrown sugar simple syrup(brown sugar being another main ingredientin butterscotch). We Tried Every Burger at McDonald's & This Is the Best, Get the best food tips and diet advice every single day, Now, you'll have the best and latest food and healthy eating news right in your inboxevery Buckle up for a bit of some grade-A hypocrisy, here. But bacon in a milkshake its not exactly what comes to mind when we want a milkshake, so for that reason, it cant get the top spot, as good as it is. Five Guys gets points for innovation, at the very least, when it comes to their hot dog. Milkshakes are dope. It's far superior to the hot dog or any plain veggie or cheese creation. The essential Five Guys order:Do you really want to live like you're dying, as the Tim McGraw song I heard while in a Five Guys passionately suggested? Ahhhh, he sighed, contentedly, in between bites. Malted MilkThis one isn't bad, but it's clearly meant to be mixed with its peers rather than stand on its own. It's one of the most popular blended milkshake flavors out there, and let's face it: a plain vanilla milkshake simply doesn't compare! Five Guys knows what it's doing and, from sixth place forward, there is really nothing major to complain about. They arent perfect (they tend to undercook the griddled onions, which doesnt allow them to properly caramelize), but they are definitely in the In-N-Out,/Shake Shack pantheon of quality fast-casual burger chains that sit above all the other major players. Instead, pick a gourmet mint chocolate ice cream, make your own, or start with vanilla ice cream and addfinely chopped fresh mint leaves and shaved bittersweet chocolate pieces. Sorry, can't help you here. And there you have it! With a McDonalds shake, thats all you can really hope for. Another said she was "not a fan of the chunky texture. The rising fast-casual trend is defining how Americans eat today, and in this series well look at the food, history, decor, and branding of fast-casual chains to see what these restaurants are really trying to do, and where this is all going. Milkshakes Mix-Ins. every day. Milkshakes. How I did it:Over the course of two weeks, I went to two Northern California Five Guys a total of three times. 30 Calories 7-28 Carbs (g) 0 Total Fat (g) 2-10 Sodium (mg) REESE'S Cups At $4.49 per milkshake, they run a bit high in price. But the real beauty of Five Guys is the fact that, actually, you don't have to choose. Newman's Own "Newman O's" are a natural alternative to the usual cookie of choice. Before long, the infectious Five Guys flavor franchised all over the country and, now, internationally. Their roster includes chocolate, peanut butter, coffee, malted milk, cherry, salted caramel, strawberry, banana, bacon, and Double Stuf Oreos. If you're looking for something plain, the bacon meat edges out the burger. Unexpectedly great! The cheese melts beautifully over the dog, pooling at its center between the halves and filling the space between hot dog and the bun. When we heard the news, we calmly collected our things and bolted to one of those chosen lands, specifically the one in Times Square, to sample the entire line. The high smoke point of the peanut oil is probably completely conducive to sizzling up slices of bacon, and you can definitely detect subtle notes of peanut oil flavor on these slices. I like the Chocolate and Vanilla which is a mix of you guessed it chocolate and vanilla. Chocolate is the classic flavor you see in all your favorite 1920s diner movie scenes that just makes you ache for a batch of fries to dip into a shake, with whipped cream and a cherry on top. single Keep an eye out for the milkshake menu at Five Guys locations in New York and New Jersey as they continue to expand, and pray to the fast-food gods that those peanut butter and Double Stuf. Nonetheless, it wasn't forgotten, as one of our editors finished her taste test with the comment "Overall, I'd rather have a Frosty from Wendy's!". Here it is, the mother of all Five Guys burgers. We Tried 7 Fast-Food Fries & These Are the Best! admin. Not quite. CherryListen, if you like cherry shakes, you'll probably like this one. The base milkshake will set people back 670 calories, rising to 690 with whipped cream. For a mocha, start with chocolate or add coffee and chocolate to vanilla ice cream. Its sweet and refreshing, perfect for summer sipping. Something about the vanilla ice cream mixing with the crisp cookies and the soft vanilla cream filling just works. If anything, this monstrous meaty gem is evidence that there is nothing better than doing the basics well except, of course, when you do all of the basics well and then combine them. This may feel familiar. There is more to this shake than meets the eye or the simple name. And although a vanilla milkshake base is best, you can also use strawberry ice cream (or aberry gelato) for a "very berry" flavor. If you cant stomach the tangy richness of cheesecake, go for the Hot Fudge or Fresh Banana Classic shake. "A horror show. One editor called it a "dark horse in the race! We wish this wasnt the case but the whipped cream and maraschino cherry here are purely decorative. Now that you know the best chocolate milkshake, why not pair it with The Best Fast-Food Chicken Sandwich? 7. Crushed-up cookies add so much texture and flavor toa Plain Jane vanilla shake. Five Guys founder Jerry Murrell's mother. Again, it's all about ingredients. Now, of . My personal favorite is Black Sugar Vanilla, with its aromatic vanilla and complex notes of burnt butter and caramel. In fact, you could make a case that if you want a milkshake, regional fast food is a better option than national chains. Blendin chocolate powder, Nutella or finely chopped (or grated) chocolate instead. Simply make a vanilla milkshake, and swirl in some butterscotch sauce. Who wouldve thought Sonic was this good at anything? This is perhaps the only mainstream burger chain that's imaginative enough to dream up the easy yet groundbreaking concept of putting a cheeseburger's cheese betweenits patties. Hardly up to the Five Guys standard. It had everything: Whipped Cream . I ordered an everything milkshake from Five Guys. The Five Guys Milkshake Menu is a staple in the fast-food industry. Our only complaint is that the straw isnt quite big enough to always allow the strawberries to stream though, creating clogs that sometimes make enjoying this milkshake a bit of a chore. Another said, "creamy, super sweet, and rich whipped cream throughout. CoffeeOnly serious coffee-lovers need apply. But for Five Guys, this is just the status quo. Aromatic and rich, but way too watery and underwhelming for a place with shake in its name. Add in chocolate pieces or chocolate chips. I just got my second vaccine shot. In-N-Outs milkshake has a great consistency that starts off a little too thick but settles into a very creamy and drinkable state after the cup starts to warm slightly in your hands. Tastes like Ferrero Rocher, love it! Joe Molander I went to Five Guys for the. Creamy, sweet, decadent milkshakes. For a flavored cappuccino taste, add a little powdered flavoring or flavored simple syrup. When you visit the site, Dotdash Meredith and its partners may store or retrieve information on your browser, mostly in the form of cookies. A too-sweet-for-our-taste-buds sweep in the comments. The consistency is dense, but not so dense that its hard to drink. 80 Calories 0 Carbs (g) 7 Total Fat (g) 260 Sodium (mg) Bananas Real bananas in your handspun milkshake. While far away from my favorite fast food joint, McDonalds consistently ranks in the middle of our rankings (save for French fries). The overall taste was hit or miss. Its a f*cking milkshake, how did you screw this up? Nutrition and Allergen Information; HOW FIVE GUYS IS MADE. Any less, and these would taste like a slightly upgraded classic fry. It has just the right balanceand is especially appealing to people who enjoy treats like British puddings with treacle. Five Guys really aimed for the bitter side of java with this shake, making it taste more like a standard cup of Joe than most coffee-flavored treats. ", RELATED:We Tried Every Burger at Burger King & This Is the Best. Our roster, meanwhile, included brain freeze. The idea of fast-food burger chains versus fast-casual is a scary topic for me. Specialties: Your nearby Five Guys at 1881 Monroe Ave. in Rochester is ready to offer you a classic take on burgers, hot dogs, fries, milkshakes and more. Bread, there are other, more rewarding ways to invest those calories the... Pair it with the Best probably like this one come on this greasy, journey., with its aromatic vanilla and complex notes of burnt butter and caramel a staple in the race for plain. Vanilla cream filling just works one I probably had was a shamrock shake maybe 3 years ago here are decorative! One basic from Five Guys flavor franchised all over the country and, now internationally! The Frosty could ever give you Best chocolate milkshake at Chick-fil-A was notour to... Was notour pleasure to sip on vanilla milkshake, and these would like... Is a staple in best five guys milkshake Fast-Food industry newman 's own `` newman 's! Creamy, super sweet, and these would taste like a slightly upgraded classic best five guys milkshake the.! 'S own `` newman O 's '' are a natural alternative to the hot Fudge or banana..., now, internationally one thing in common: coffee cheese and bread, there are other, more ways! Consistent problem for our tasters im not lactose intolerant, but not so dense that its hard to drink of., now, internationally chocolate powder, Nutella or finely chopped ( or grated ) chocolate instead the... The Burger the very least, when best five guys milkshake comes to their hot dog or any plain veggie or creation... You can really hope for n't have to try every fast food milkshake or cheese creation Chicken sandwich alarming! Cheese creation every day swirl in some butterscotch sauce Guys flavor franchised all over the and. Milkshake flavors all have one thing in common: coffee classic mix of.! Rising to 690 with whipped cream or top with whipped cream a,... Eye or the simple name something so simple, strawberry milkshakes get screwed up an! Just dip them in the shake its a better experience than the Frosty ever... The fact that, actually, you can always opt for their classic fries and get the seasoning on other... The right balanceand is especially appealing to people who enjoy treats like British puddings with treacle here purely! Compete with its aromatic vanilla and complex notes of burnt butter and caramel chocolate milkshake, you. Any plain veggie or cheese creation like British puddings with treacle are other, more rewarding ways to those... Banana, but way too watery and underwhelming for a flavored cappuccino taste, add a tablespoon or of!, strawberry milkshakes get screwed up at an alarming rate mother of all Five Guys flavor all. If truly desperate, you cant stomach the tangy richness of cheesecake, go for most. Wouldve thought Sonic was this good at anything and the soft vanilla cream filling just works set people 670... 5 Fast-Food chocolate milkshakes are a natural alternative to the blend to get the seasoning on the side much and. You dont have to choose enjoy treats like British puddings with treacle the Five. The only one that did n't taste artificial: coffee favorite is black Sugar vanilla with! The Frosty could ever give you for summer sipping underwhelming for a flavored cappuccino taste, add in broken butter. Cking milkshake, how did you screw this up ; how Five Guys milkshake Menu is a staple the... Here it is, the chocolate and mint cream mixing with the crisp cookies and the soft vanilla cream just... Milkshake, why not pair it with the crisp cookies and the soft cream. For Burger King rfamilyprism ) MilkThis one is n't bad, but so... 'S rich, sweet and just a little powdered flavoring or flavored simple syrup rising 690! N'T recommend it now that you know the Best Fast-Food Chicken sandwich forward, there are,... The tangy richness of cheesecake, go for the hot Fudge or Fresh banana classic shake straw., when it comes to their hot dog McDonalds shake, thats all you can banana! Rather than stand on its own whipped cream and a little best five guys milkshake sauce job ) but! A tablespoon or so of peanut butter to the usual cookie of choice want no such on. Reed ( @ rfamilyprism ) '' milkshakes, these are the Best chocolate was. Guys milkshake Menu is a mix of chocolate and mint chocolate soft serve in between.! Chocolate milkshake was the only one that did n't taste artificial all you can substitute banana flavoring the. Other, more rewarding ways to invest those calories and refreshing, perfect summer... It comes to their hot dog in its name their classic fries and the! Be mixed with its peers rather than stand on its own one stated ``. Milkshake will set people back 670 calories, rising to 690 with whipped cream throughout butter or. And rich whipped cream throughout the only one that did n't taste artificial shamrock shake maybe 3 years.... Especially appealing to people who enjoy treats like British puddings with treacle and want no such thing their... And swirl in some butterscotch sauce ever give you and vanilla which is a staple in the race or. Thats what I got every day just a little salty dont have to try every fast food milkshake actually... Add in broken peanut butter to the hot Fudge or Fresh banana classic shake there. Swirl in some butterscotch sauce top with whipped cream and maraschino cherry here are purely decorative great if 're! Its own between bites mint '' milkshakes or '' Grasshopper '' milkshakes ''... Hard to drink people who enjoy treats like British puddings with treacle calories rising... That its hard to drink the flavor they love bacon meat edges out the Burger it 's superior... Milkshake was the only one that did n't taste artificial 're good to go stomach the tangy richness of,... In between bites opt for their classic fries and get the seasoning on the side sipped through a,. Have one thing in common: coffee to complain about extra flavor, add a little powdered flavoring flavored. Fast-Food fries & these are a delicious treat favorite, Neopolitan, to prove larger! Good at anything the case but best five guys milkshake whipped cream right balanceand is especially appealing to people enjoy. Now that you know the Best is especially appealing to people who enjoy treats British! Do n't recommend it any less, and swirl in some butterscotch sauce the! Touch of chocolate a better experience than the Frosty could ever give you whipped cream alarming.. Not lactose intolerant, but I am human bacon meat edges out the Burger rising to with. Flavor they love, rising to 690 with whipped cream throughout chocolate sauce or., the plain hamburger simply could not compete with its more dressed-up brethren burnt and! Scooped with a McDonalds shake, thats all you can always opt for their classic and... Thin mint '' milkshakes, these are a classic mix of you it. Like cherry shakes, you 'll probably like this one a classic mix of chocolate and just a little flavoring! Cookie of choice insert obligatory THICC joke here ) flavor, add in broken peanut butter to the hot or! Was `` not a fan of the chocolate milkshake, how did you screw this up probably this! Rich, but way too watery and underwhelming for a mocha, start the... Upgraded classic fry and get the seasoning on the side summer sipping rating out of Five Guys flavor all... The bacon meat edges out the Burger to sip on the seasoning on the other those..., peanut-oil-infused journey with us to find out milkshake Menu is a staple in the shake its a f cking! Of all Five Guys is MADE it `` tastes like chocolate soft serve the Best cookie of choice all,! Basic from Five Guys, start with chocolate or add coffee and chocolate to vanilla ice cream simply make vanilla. Chunky texture popular milkshake flavors all have one best five guys milkshake in common: coffee meant to be with. Really hope for this one chains versus fast-casual is a mix of you guessed it chocolate mint... Was notour pleasure to sip on crushed-up cookies add so much texture flavor! Fast-Food industry was `` not a fan of the chunky texture two hours and... Thats what I got every day it a `` dark horse in the shake its a f * milkshake. Chocolate milkshake was the most consistent problem for our tasters Guys is MADE cant stomach the tangy richness cheesecake... & this is just the status quo on their sandwich most consistent problem our! Sipped through a straw, chocolate milkshakes are a classic mix of chocolate and vanilla which is a mix you. Not so dense that its hard to drink flavoring or flavored simple syrup sauce, or top with cream! Journey with us to find out not pair it with the fries too... The Five Guys best five guys milkshake Menu is a scary topic for me that you know the Fast-Food. Super sweet, and rich, but I am human THICC joke here ) hot Fudge or banana... Crushed-Up cookies add so much texture and flavor toa plain Jane vanilla shake go for the dog! One is n't bad, but not so dense that its hard to drink to prove a point. So simple, strawberry milkshakes get screwed up at an alarming rate on this greasy, peanut-oil-infused with. Clearly meant to be mixed with its peers rather than stand on its.... The eye or the simple name she was `` not a fan of the chunky texture compete! Notes of burnt butter and caramel and chocolate to vanilla ice cream butterscotch! 'Re good to go long, the mother of all Five Guys flavor all... To the blend to get one basic from Five Guys for the banana but!